All have heard it, but STILL NO SALES.

Discussion started by Shermadini

I know, I know. It takes a LONG time to sell a model, but how do these random models get on the trending page with almost no views?(no offense if its yours:)) I just want to know some secrets!

Answers

Posted over 5 years ago
3

I am not sure what the mechanism with trending models is, but sometimes it looks strange to me as well.
Anyway, if you have no sales you can try Turbosquid. Lately I am having better sales there.

Shermadini wrote
Shermadini
I sell on Turbosquid as well, but I just don’t like their design and site overall. Publishing models takes a lot longer too, here it take a second. One thing I like about turbosquid is that my models appear on the very first pages when searching for them, but no sales there, too. Guess I’m just doing something wrong.
John-Kairi wrote
John-Kairi
copy trending model name and tags it works but even if your model is on trending page u will not get any sell
Posted over 5 years ago
1

The system for trending models looks at frequency of interactions (in time) at moment of going public, no secrets. The only secret is maybe most of those trending artists have a network and at moment of publishing they pull in as mush views as they can from that network.

Regarding your low sales;
My personal view is its due to having few models and at same time having items that are in heavily overcrowded category.

You can get knowledge about what is in demand if you use the Analytics tool,
(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xI_HpXuPWms) create for those categories and you get lots of sales.

@PrintedReality, I closed my account on Tutbosquid after price guarantee madness went up, its a very expensive platform and now they restrict artists from adding that cots to the product, that's just total madness. But they can be as cray as they want when people don't realize it (or care) and keep supporting it. Anyways, few sales I had there added up here, so in my case clients just follow where my stuff is. It proves clients have at least two accounts (or they make one), they are not loyal to one platform, I lost no sale closing my Turbosquid account. Your very likely loosing money if you sell on both sites (not exclusive with Turbosquid), on other hand, its unwise to go exclusive in a time where more opportunity’s open up for sellers.

Shermadini wrote
Shermadini
I mean, yes CGtrader 100% better in every way, but how could I be losing sales when selling on 2 or more sites? Isn't it better, especially for a beginner like me?
iterateCGI wrote
iterateCGI
Keep in mind sales is most important factor to up-rank your models, where do you want best ranking?
Posted over 5 years ago
3

If you run Website analyses on Turbosquid and CGtrader, you discover they both get around 5 million visitors per month (Ts get some more but allow me to elaborate later why this makes no difference).

The main thing to keep in mind is there are not 10 million users out there, (one half Ts users, other half CGt users) they are just the same people, its 5 million “same” people that both visit Ts and CGt every month. They all have multiple accounts and they buy where they happen to be and have some items already in the shopping cart. What they do is hopping back and fort searching and comparing content on both sites to see where they get best match on what they need. If they happen to be on Ts and have some items already in the basket and encounter some nice stuff on CGt then they just continue to checkout at Ts and then login to CGt to get that additional item (and visa versa). The thing is if your items happen to be in the Ts basket at that time then they are not gonna be added in the CGt basket (why would they, price is same right?).

Likelihood where a given user is going to check out is almost 50% ration now because CGt has content Ts has not and vise versa. However, there is small discrepancy towards Ts, 53% of times a user will likely checkout at Ts and 47% of times a user will likely checkout at CGt, why is that? (note this does not mean you have 6% more chance selling on Ts)

The small difference is due to fact that Ts has been around longer and they still have a considerable amount of exclusive artist and in addition still some work from non exclusive artists (priced same as elsewhere now), so the content is not evenly distributed (Ts has still a small edge on that), however it does not make a difference, users login to the CGt account if they encounter content they like and is not available on Ts.

If you sold something on Ts its not that you could not have sold your item here at CGt, you just have chosen to sell it on Ts and influence your own believe system, that’s all. Ts is not particularly better at selling your items, its just the old habits of the users (in decline now) plus people that keep selling on both sites. This influences the small discrepancy and likelihood where a given user is going to check out with your models at a given time.

Lastly, do not believe Ts has some hidden clients that never discovered CGt, that's just silly.
Just leverage the better royalty to successfully compete with Ts and clients will more likely checkout with your models here.

Shermadini wrote
Shermadini
Thanks! I will definitely keep this in mind. May do some changes. Thank you for explaining!
Posted over 5 years ago
-1

@interateCGI I don't know where you took those statistics from. Assumption that there is 5 million users with multiple accounts on TS and CGTrader cannot be right. I don't think that there is a specific number of your sales a month and you are choosing whether you will have all those sales on CGTrader or both of those. You seem to be assuming that every sale comes from Google search and then buyers decide whether they go with CGTrader or TS. However I don't think it as simple as that. For example the important factor is the positioning of your models on each of those website. If my model is on page 5 on CGTrader and page 2 on TS then obviously I have a better chance of selling this model on TS.
This month I have 2x better sales on TS (last year I had much better sales on CGTrader). I have a lot of my models still with higher price on TS and even though they are getting sold, so no, those buyers obviously didn't see my models on CGTrader.

Shermadini wrote
Shermadini
true, true. My models are always on first 2 pages on TS, but here you have to filter 10 times to find them.
Posted over 5 years ago
1

@PrintedReality, for clarification, it’s around 5 million “visits” on each site, not 5 million multiple account holders. Don’t have correct numbers on total accounts but for CGt its around 1.5 million fresh accounts (https://www.tctmagazine.com/3d-printing-news/cgtrader-reaches-1-5-million-users/) according to this news article (I believe its also on the blog here somewhere). I bet you they all have Ts account as well (active or inactive).

Ts has probably some more accounts but again I would argue it does not matter. Note Ts was there way before CGt and lots of old accounts are still there but not active (also lots of people left after price guarantee, those accounts would still register but they are mostly inactive).

You do make the choice, you are swinging your own clients.

@Shermandini, the problem of your position here will not change if you keep a profile at Ts, sales is most important factor to get better position, if you direct your clients to Ts then that is where you get better position and more sales. Just ask yourself where do you want better position? Its not wise to compete with your own less expensive profile against an expensive one (you lose money). Keep in mind they also compete in Google ranking.

Its perfectly doable to get all your sales at the place you want and not lose a single client and earn more, I did it.

Shermadini wrote
Shermadini
Yes, but I am not sure yet. One of my model, which is free has way more downloads there, than here and they show up on the first few pages when searching for key words. But conditions are better here and TS doesn't treat sellers very well in terms of what percentage they pay us. I will keep everything in mind and decide what to do next. Thanks to you both.
Posted over 5 years ago
0

I wouldn't listen much to what iterateCGI says abut TS, he sings that same anti squid song for years. Yes they are bad, they treat sellers like scum and pays pennies for our work, but if you think that if you'd close you shop at squid, sales in cgtrader would increase significantly, then you simply deceiving yourself. Customers won't follow you. With few rare exceptions, they don't know who you are and they don't care about you. If they're shopping on squid, it's not because of YOU and if you withdraw your models from there, they will find another model there. If you're making very unique, bespoke models, then to some degree customers might follow you and search for YOUR models. That can be partially applicable to iterateCGI and Printed Reality. But someone with generic models, will loose all the sales at squid, the moment they close the shop and none of them will transfer to CGT. I have pretty established position at TS and sales goes at par with cgtrader. It brakes my heart to see how TS is literally robbing me, but i know for sure that i would loose good portion of my income if i'd close the shop.

iterateCGI wrote
iterateCGI
I’m sorry to see you say that lemonadeCG, the only reason people believe this is because there are so many of you that keep feeding Ts with your work and make realty like so (for yourself). I do not believe you care Ts is robbing you, its because of people like you this is happening so just blame yourself. I will keep singing the same song thank you, just trying to help people see it can be different. You probably are right sales will drop for some time but it will stabilize. You do not need to believe it but keeping others in your same fear state is not helping. There are lots of you in this state and you all just keep yourself in this state until you brake out of it.
ldesign3dstudio wrote
ldesign3dstudio
TS may take a much bigger cut, but their customer support is out of this world compared to CGT. As a customer, you can contact them 24/7 and receive an instant response. You need any model converted to any format? It will be ready in less than an hour, even if the seller included only one format. The point is, if customer isn't 100% confident in your model, you will never make a sale here, but on TS you have much better opportunities, your models have added value, especially if you certify them. In my opinion, both markets are great for their own purpose. I'm thankful for CGT because they broke the TS monopoly and allowed us to diversify our risks. But at the same time, CGT is not really trying in many areas, it seems like they are happy with the status quo. To me, Turbosquid will always be the king, mainly for their efforts to move the industry forward.
Posted over 5 years ago
0

Hey, but it is kinda true. You know, I never go on TS or CGt just to find my favorite sellers work. I just search for model I need and that’s it. No one really cares who you are, unless you are really big in this industry. For now I will leave everything as it is.

iterateCGI wrote
iterateCGI
This is funny, so your actually saying it yourself? lets recap, so when your on Ts and you see what you need then you just buy it there? No need to see if price is lower somewhere ells right? Maybe just a little check if CGt has something Ts has not? Maybe they have something similar but better priced? If yes then use CGt account?
Posted over 5 years ago
1

I have never really bought anything from any of these websites, but I have downloaded a few free models from many sites for my game project. I just find what I need and leave, if it is not there I make model myself, but how will uploading on multiple sites harm my sales, when I am still testing and figuring things out. I can't really make decisions until I sell a few models.

iterateCGI wrote
iterateCGI
No problem, your absolutely free to do what you like, its all up to you. Just feel a need to react to these types of forum entry’s (don’t take it personal), with tittles like “all have heard it but no sales”, etc. There are many of you simultaneously up-ranking a Ts account, helping traffic to it and then starting these types of forum entry’s here. New promising artists but also existing Ts artists lingering to leave the Ts extortion read this (unrepresentative info) and it gets part of a wrong perception (just enforcing each others doubts). Then they think ok we need Ts, “but its not”, you don't need such expensive platform at all. There are lots of successful sellers here but they just don’t feel the need to tell about it in the forum. Its mainly complainers coming in here telling these types of things and the forum gets all these, “catchy problematic titles” that do not match with whats going on. The realty is most of the time these forum entry's are made by people that swing own clients to direction of expensive Ts account, keep the place up and expect the CGt account to somehow up-ranks itself while dividing against it. So ones again, all 3D stock customers have at least two accounts and use one or other only when needed. The people that use only one account are very few, not worth losing 60% on all others for those few. O and remember, Ts deletes forum entry's like this or moves them to a place you never find them. PS: my story here (https://www.cgtrader.com/forum/general-discussions/why-i-left-turbosquid)
Posted about 5 years ago
0

我也是啊

Your answer

In order to post an answer, you need to sign in.

Help
Chat