3
3d-noob
As a Cinema4D/Redshift user, I'll review the FBX version only:
-------
Pros:
The mesh looks fine and detailed enough; edges are beveled and appear ready for sub-division (which does not seem necessary though).
The 4K textures look OK, for close-up renders they could be higher resolution.
-------
Cons:
The boat and all its accessories are one mesh (FBX and OBJ files). I would have preferred to have, for example, the oars as separated meshes to make animating the model easier.
-------
Suggestions:
I realize that the boat is supposed to be "old" but "new" textures as an addition would be nice.
-------
Overall: recommended